Thanksgiving is one of the most widely recognized holidays in the United States, celebrated each year with family meals, traditional foods and gatherings. However, the history of Thanksgiving extends far beyond the modern holiday. Its origins involve Indigenous harvest traditions, English colonization, a 17th-century harvest celebration, presidential proclamations and federal legislation.
The event commonly described as the First Thanksgiving took place in Plymouth in 1621, when English colonists and members of the Wampanoag community gathered during the autumn harvest season. The holiday celebrated today developed over several centuries and was not established as a national annual holiday until much later.
Understanding Thanksgiving history requires examining historical records, the experiences of the Wampanoag people and the political decisions that shaped the holiday. These details help explain how a harvest gathering became an enduring part of American history.
Long before English settlers arrived in New England, Indigenous peoples throughout North America maintained traditions connected to seasonal changes, harvests, community life and gratitude. These traditions varied between nations and reflected their distinct cultural practices, environments and relationships with the land.
For the Wampanoag people, whose homeland includes parts of present-day southeastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island, seasonal harvests and giving thanks were already important parts of life. Their traditions did not begin with the arrival of English colonists or the gathering remembered as the First Thanksgiving.
Indigenous communities relied on extensive knowledge of local ecosystems, agriculture, fishing, hunting and gathering. Their food systems were shaped by seasonal availability and generations of experience with the natural environment. Harvest gatherings were therefore part of broader cultural and community traditions rather than a single event that created Thanksgiving.
The Smithsonian's National Museum of the American Indian emphasizes that Indigenous traditions of gratitude existed long before the establishment of the American national holiday. It also explains that Native nations have distinct traditions that should not be treated as one uniform culture.
This historical context is essential because Thanksgiving is often presented as though the practice of giving thanks began with the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag in 1621. In reality, Indigenous traditions of gratitude and seasonal celebration have much older and more diverse histories.
The story commonly associated with Thanksgiving begins with the English colonists who crossed the Atlantic aboard the Mayflower in 1620. They reached the region of present-day Massachusetts and established the Plymouth settlement.
The first winter was extremely difficult for the colonists. Disease, inadequate shelter, limited supplies and harsh weather contributed to widespread suffering. Many of those who had arrived aboard the Mayflower died during the first winter.
The Wampanoag people had lived in the region for generations before the English settlement was established. Their experiences with European visitors also predated the Mayflower's arrival. European exploration, trade, enslavement and introduced diseases had already affected Indigenous communities in the region.
In the spring of 1621, Wampanoag leader Ousamequin, often referred to in English colonial accounts as Massasoit, entered into an agreement with Plymouth governor John Carver. The agreement concerned mutual protection and relations between the two groups.
The relationship was shaped by political considerations, diplomacy and the circumstances facing both communities. It should not be reduced to a simple story of immediate friendship. The Wampanoag were an established people with their own leadership, territory and political interests, while the English settlement was attempting to survive in an unfamiliar environment.
The Smithsonian's historical resources explain that Wampanoag assistance to the colonists occurred within a complex political relationship. Although cooperation took place, the relationship between Indigenous peoples and English settlers changed over time as colonial expansion affected Native lands and communities.
Understanding this background provides a more complete explanation of the events leading up to the 1621 harvest gathering.
The event remembered as the First Thanksgiving took place in the autumn of 1621, following the English colonists' first successful harvest at Plymouth. However, the surviving historical records do not establish an exact calendar date for the gathering.
The most detailed account comes from Edward Winslow, an English colonist who described the harvest celebration in a letter dated December 11, 1621. His account was later published in Mourt's Relation, a work describing the early Plymouth settlement.
According to Winslow, the governor sent four men to hunt birds after the harvest had been gathered. The colonists then celebrated, and a large group of Wampanoag people, including Ousamequin, joined them. Winslow recorded that approximately 90 Wampanoag men were present and that the gathering lasted three days.
The Pilgrim Hall Museum identifies 53 surviving Mayflower colonists as participants in the harvest event, although the original written account does not provide a complete attendance list. The Indigenous attendance figure comes from Winslow's account and may not represent every person present.
The gathering included food, hunting and recreational Halloween activities. Winslow's description indicates that the Wampanoag participants brought five deer to the settlement. The account does not describe a formal Thanksgiving holiday as Americans understand it today.
The gathering is historically significant because it documents an occasion when English colonists and Wampanoag people came together after the colonists' harvest. However, the surviving account was written from the English perspective and does not fully explain how the Wampanoag participants understood or experienced the event.
For this reason, historians distinguish the 1621 harvest gathering from the national holiday that developed centuries later.
The modern Thanksgiving meal is commonly associated with roast turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, pumpkin pie and other dishes. However, there is no complete menu from the 1621 harvest gathering, so it would be inaccurate to claim that the colonists served the same meal that appears on modern Thanksgiving tables.
Historical records provide some evidence about the food available in Plymouth during this period. Edward Winslow described the hunting of birds and the presence of Wampanoag visitors who brought deer. William Bradford, another early Plymouth leader, also wrote about the colony's food supplies during the autumn.
Bradford mentioned wild turkeys, venison, fish and Indian corn when describing food available around the time of the harvest. His account provides useful information about the settlement's food resources, but it does not establish that every item he mentioned was served at the three-day gathering.
The evidence supports the possibility that the meal included wildfowl and venison, alongside foods available through local agriculture, fishing and gathering. However, the precise menu remains uncertain.
Several popular Thanksgiving dishes cannot be confirmed as part of the 1621 meal. There is no surviving evidence establishing that pumpkin pie, mashed potatoes or cranberry sauce was served at the gathering in its modern form.
This distinction between historical evidence and later tradition is important. Thanksgiving foods evolved over time, influenced by regional ingredients, cooking practices, agricultural production and changing American food culture.
The most accurate conclusion is that the 1621 gathering featured food associated with the harvest and the resources available to the people who attended, but its exact menu is not known.
Historical research depends on surviving documents, contemporary accounts and careful interpretation. The 1621 harvest gathering is a useful example of why historians must distinguish between what written records confirm and what later generations have assumed.
Two important English sources describe the events surrounding Plymouth's 1621 harvest. The first is Edward Winslow's account, published in Mourt's Relation in 1622. The second is William Bradford's history of Plymouth Colony, later published as Of Plymouth Plantation.
Winslow provides the clearest description of the gathering, including the hunting of birds, the arrival of Wampanoag visitors, the presence of approximately 90 men and the three-day feast. Bradford describes the colony's harvest, food supplies and conditions during the same period.
However, these sources have limitations. Both were written from the English colonists' perspective. They do not provide a complete account of the Wampanoag participants' experiences, intentions or understanding of the event. There is no surviving Wampanoag eyewitness account that describes the gathering in equivalent detail.
Historians therefore compare the English documents with other historical evidence and Indigenous perspectives to build a more complete picture. They also avoid treating details from later Thanksgiving traditions as though they were recorded in 1621.
The available records establish that a harvest gathering occurred and that Wampanoag people participated. They do not establish every detail of the meal, its precise date or the idea that those present intended to establish an annual national holiday.
The 1621 harvest celebration was not the beginning of a continuous annual Thanksgiving holiday. During the colonial period, days of thanksgiving could be designated for different reasons, including religious observances, military developments, favorable events and successful harvests.
These occasions did not necessarily take place in November or follow a uniform national schedule. Their timing and purpose varied between communities and colonies.
Plymouth Colony itself observed other thanksgiving occasions. For example, a day of thanksgiving was held in 1623 after a period of drought ended following prayers for rain. This was a separate event from the 1621 harvest gathering and illustrates how the term thanksgiving was associated with religious observance as well as seasonal abundance.
As the English colonies developed, thanksgiving observances continued to vary by location. Some communities organized special days in response to particular events, while others maintained religious traditions that emphasized gratitude.
This history explains why the 1621 gathering should not be confused with the beginning of an uninterrupted annual holiday. Thanksgiving developed gradually through different local customs, religious practices and later national decisions.
One of the most influential figures in the development of modern Thanksgiving was Sarah Josepha Hale, an American writer and editor. During the 19th century, Hale campaigned for a nationally recognized Thanksgiving holiday that would be observed annually.
Through editorials, magazine articles and correspondence with political leaders, she promoted the idea that a common day of thanksgiving could become a shared American tradition. Her campaign continued for decades and helped bring national attention to the holiday.
Hale's work was part of a broader cultural movement to establish common American customs during a period when regional identities remained strong. Thanksgiving already had a history of local observance, but the timing and status of the holiday were not consistent throughout the country.
Her campaign contributed to the national recognition of Thanksgiving, although she was not solely responsible for its establishment. The federal government's eventual adoption of the holiday also reflected political decisions and the circumstances of the Civil War.
The popular story of the 1621 gathering gained wider attention during the 19th century. The rediscovery and circulation of early English accounts helped shape the image of the Pilgrims and Wampanoag sharing a harvest meal. Over time, this image became closely connected to the idea of a national Thanksgiving tradition.
A major milestone in Thanksgiving history occurred on October 3, 1863, when President Abraham Lincoln issued a proclamation calling for a national day of thanksgiving to be observed on the final Thursday of November.
The United States was in the middle of the Civil War, which lasted from 1861 to 1865. The conflict had caused extensive casualties, destruction and uncertainty. Lincoln's proclamation called on Americans to give thanks for the country's blessings while also remembering those suffering because of the war.
The proclamation was influenced by the broader movement for a national Thanksgiving, including Sarah Josepha Hale's campaign. It gave the holiday an important place in the federal calendar and helped establish an annual November observance.
However, Lincoln's proclamation did not make Thanksgiving a permanent federal holiday on the same statutory basis that exists today. Presidential proclamations continued to play a role in determining its observance, and the date was later standardized through federal legislation.
The 1863 proclamation is significant because it established the tradition of a regularly observed national Thanksgiving in November. It also connected the holiday with themes of gratitude, national reflection and unity during a period of severe division.
Thanksgiving's current date was established through a series of decisions during the 20th century. Although the holiday had become a regular November observance, the exact date was not permanently fixed as the fourth Thursday until 1941.
In 1939, the final Thursday of November fell on November 30. President Franklin D. Roosevelt decided to move Thanksgiving to the second-to-last Thursday of the month. His administration was concerned that a later Thanksgiving would shorten the Christmas shopping season and potentially affect economic recovery during the Great Depression.
The change created disagreement across the country. According to the National Archives, 32 states adopted the earlier date while 16 states continued to observe Thanksgiving on the traditional final Thursday. For two years, different parts of the country celebrated the holiday on different dates.
To resolve the confusion, Congress considered legislation to establish a consistent date. The House initially supported the last Thursday of November, but the Senate amended the measure to specify the fourth Thursday. This distinction allowed for years when November has five Thursdays.
President Roosevelt signed the resolution on December 26, 1941, establishing the fourth Thursday in November as the federal Thanksgiving Day holiday.
Today, Thanksgiving is observed on the fourth Thursday of November in the United States. In 2026, it falls on Thursday, November 26.
A complete account of Thanksgiving history must include the experiences and perspectives of Indigenous peoples, particularly the Wampanoag, whose ancestors participated in the 1621 harvest gathering.
Traditional schoolbook accounts have often presented the event as a simple story of friendship between English settlers and Native Americans. Historical evidence, however, shows that relations involved diplomacy, political interests, cooperation and competing understandings of agreements.
The Wampanoag people had their own communities, leadership structures and established relationships with neighboring nations long before the English settlement. Their assistance to the colonists took place within this broader context, not simply as an act of friendship between strangers.
Over time, English settlement expanded, bringing major changes to Indigenous communities. Colonial expansion, land dispossession, disease, violence and conflict had devastating effects on Native peoples. The relationship between the Wampanoag and English colonists also changed significantly after the 1621 gathering.
The Smithsonian's National Museum of the American Indian emphasizes that the popular Thanksgiving narrative is incomplete when it leaves out Indigenous perspectives and the broader history of colonization. Recognizing these experiences does not require ignoring the historical gathering; it requires understanding it within its full historical context.
Thanksgiving also has different meanings for different people today. Many Americans celebrate it as a time for family, gratitude and community, while some Indigenous people use the day to remember their ancestors, reflect on the effects of colonization and raise awareness of Native history and rights.
These perspectives are part of the holiday's continuing history and should be represented accurately and respectfully.
The National Day of Mourning is an Indigenous-led observance held in Plymouth, Massachusetts, on Thanksgiving Day. It provides an opportunity to remember Indigenous ancestors, acknowledge the consequences of colonization and highlight the continuing experiences and concerns of Native communities.
The observance began in 1970, when Wamsutta Frank James, a Wampanoag activist, challenged the celebratory account of the Pilgrim story being used for a commemoration marking the 350th anniversary of the Mayflower's arrival. James and other Indigenous activists brought attention to Native history and the impact of European colonization.
Since then, Indigenous people and their supporters have gathered in Plymouth for the National Day of Mourning. The United American Indians of New England has helped organize the annual observance.
The day does not represent the views of every Indigenous person or nation. It is, however, an important example of how Thanksgiving's history continues to be discussed and interpreted by people whose ancestors were directly affected by colonization.
The National Day of Mourning also highlights the importance of including Indigenous voices when teaching and writing about the 1621 gathering. Historical accounts become more complete when they recognize both the surviving documents and the perspectives that those documents did not record.
Many traditions now associated with Thanksgiving developed gradually rather than appearing together in 1621. The modern holiday reflects changes in American food culture, family customs, public entertainment and national identity.
Although these customs are now familiar, they should not be projected backward onto the 1621 gathering without historical evidence. Thanksgiving traditions have continued to evolve, and families may celebrate the holiday in different ways.
Myth 1: The First Thanksgiving Had an Exact Date
Fact: The 1621 harvest gathering took place in autumn, but its exact date is unknown.
Myth 2: Thanksgiving Became an Annual Holiday in 1621
Fact: The gathering was a harvest celebration, not an official annual holiday.
Myth 3: The First Thanksgiving Featured Today's Traditional Foods
Fact: Historical records mention birds and deer, but the complete menu is unknown.
Myth 4: The Pilgrims and Wampanoag Had a Lasting Friendship
Fact: Their relationship involved diplomacy and cooperation, followed by significant conflict and colonial expansion.
Myth 5: Abraham Lincoln Created Thanksgiving
Fact: Lincoln's 1863 proclamation helped establish a national Thanksgiving tradition.
Myth 6: Thanksgiving Has Always Been on the Fourth Thursday of November
Fact: Federal legislation established the current date in 1941.
Thanksgiving's history extends from Indigenous traditions of gratitude and seasonal harvests to the 1621 gathering at Plymouth, the development of colonial observances and the creation of a national holiday.
The harvest gathering involving English colonists and Wampanoag participants was an important historical event, but it was not the beginning of the modern holiday in its current form. The national observance developed through centuries of changing customs, public campaigns and government decisions, including Lincoln's 1863 proclamation and the 1941 federal law establishing the fourth Thursday of November.
Understanding Thanksgiving also requires recognizing the perspectives of Indigenous peoples and the lasting consequences of colonization. The historical record is more complex than the familiar image of a shared meal, and examining that complexity makes the story more accurate.
By looking at primary sources, verified dates and different historical perspectives, readers can better understand how Thanksgiving developed into the holiday observed across the United States today.
The gathering commonly called the First Thanksgiving took place in the autumn of 1621 at Plymouth, in present-day Massachusetts. The surviving historical accounts do not establish an exact date.
English colonists from Plymouth and members of the Wampanoag community attended. Edward Winslow's account mentions approximately 90 Wampanoag men, while the Pilgrim Hall Museum identifies 53 surviving Mayflower colonists as participants.
Winslow's account describes the Wampanoag visitors joining the colonists for three days of feasting and Halloween activities.
The precise menu is unknown. Historical accounts mention birds and deer, while other foods were available in the region. There is no complete record confirming the modern Thanksgiving menu.
No. The 1621 event was a harvest gathering, not a nationally established annual holiday. Thanksgiving developed over subsequent centuries.
President Abraham Lincoln issued a national Thanksgiving proclamation on October 3, 1863. President George Washington had earlier proclaimed a national day of thanksgiving in 1789, but the regular November observance is associated with Lincoln's proclamation.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved the observance earlier to lengthen the Christmas shopping season during the Great Depression. The change caused disagreement between states.
President Roosevelt signed the legislation establishing the fourth Thursday of November on December 26, 1941.
The Wampanoag are an Indigenous people whose homeland includes parts of present-day southeastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island. Their ancestors participated in the 1621 harvest gathering, and their history is essential to understanding the event and the wider history of colonization.
The National Day of Mourning, established in Plymouth in 1970, provides a space to honor Indigenous ancestors, acknowledge the effects of colonization and bring attention to Native history and contemporary concerns.